How To Avoid Getting Destroyed Like Japan
Welcome to the +32 subscribers who joined this past week and are now part of 6,194 millionaires, CEO’s and high-performing entrepreneurs who read the #1 financial newsletter on Substack.
My name is Alex and I love creating streams of passive income. My goal is to help you do the same.
If you’ve enjoyed The Profit Zone please take 30 seconds out of your day to share this newsletter, leave a like, or a comment. It means the world to me and costs you a total of $0. Thank you for the support! It doesn’t go unnoticed.
Some quick but valuable investing advice:
Sometimes the gems are already in your portfolio.
I spent years trying to look for that next stock. The winner. The one that would finally “go to the moon”. But what I forgot to focus on were the positions I already had. We often think the answer to our problems is external. Something we don’t already have or haven’t found out yet. When sometimes, the answer is right under our nose.
This is why I’ve started building up the positions I already have instead of looking to add new ones. I have tons of conviction in the companies and ETFs I already own and this market is providing a great opportunity to lower your average costs across the board.
Remember: sometimes the gems you’re looking for are already in your portfolio. Keep building up your positions so you can take advantage of them.
How To Avoid Getting Destroyed Like Japan
(Written by Tyler Friesen @premium.income.investments)
This week we’re talking about something that happened over thirty years ago in the equities market!
Super relevant, I know…
Hear me out though, because I think that if you’re not careful you could become a victim of this:
This is the Japanese stock market, specifically the Nikkei 225 index. If you’re somewhat observant, you might notice something wrong with this chart…
The stocks aren’t going up!
Or at least, they haven’t recovered back to their highs in 1990. If you had a lump sum invested within a couple of year window of 1990 you still wouldn’t have a positive return! It would have actually been safer to stuff your money under the mattress then invest it into the Japanese stock market for the long haul.
But like usual, that doesn’t really show the whole picture, and that’s precisely what we’re here to do.
The Valuations Of Japanese Equities:
In this chart, you can see the PE ratio of the Nikkei 225. In 1990 the PE peaked at around 70 times before falling! Essentially, investors at the time were pricing in all the earnings until the year 2060.
Compare that to the more recent PE chart of the Nikkei:
You can see that the valuations are much more “reasonable” (although, I would say anything above 20-25 is still too expensive) in comparison to what they were during the 90s.
Personally, I think this partially explains the negative returns in the Japanese market. With an aging population and few immigrants, it’s difficult to increase profits without raising your margins or unveiling lots of new innovations. And raising margins is only something you can do so much before a competitor comes and ends the party. With such low growth, Japanese equities have had a hard time catching up to those valuations put upon them by investors in 1990. Again, based on 1990 valuations, if there was no growth in earnings we should expect Japan not to fully recover until 2060.
On The Other Hand We Have The S&P 500…
The S&P 500 in contrast to Japanese equities has never seen such high valuations, (aside from once in 2009)
I would say based on this alone, we can say that even the recent exuberance in the markets over the last decade has not been so much that we would have multiple lost decades back to back.
But let’s entertain a hypothetical question. Probably a stupid one at that, but nonetheless interesting.
What if US equities suffered the same fate as Japan with multiple decades of no growth and no recovery to the previous all-time high? Is there anything we could do?
The answer I think, is a resounding yes!
To know why though, we need to take a little trip to one of our all-time favorite books, The Intelligent Investor written by Benjamin Graham.
He describes an idea where an investor purchases stock every month regardless of the share price. This is called Dollar Cost Averaging (or DCA for short).
DCAing into the Japanese equity market drastically changes our return profile.
The CAGR (compound annual growth rate) for a lump sum investment into Japanese equities in 1990 is -0.88% with inflation tacked on, that’s a -1.28% CAGR. (Japan has only experienced 13.59% cumulative inflation since 1990)
By contrast, the CAGR we get from Dollar Cost Averaging is a bit harder to calculate because of the lack of good data available, however, it is higher.
We’ll use Portfolio Visualizer to give us a final figure of the size of our portfolio, however, it does not get any Japanese stock data before the year 1996. So we can calculate the percentage drop from 1990 to 1996 and then use the amount we have in 1996 to plug into Portfolio Visualizer.
Percentage loss from 1990 to 1996: 47.9% drop
CAGR from 1990 to 1996: -8.7%
Assume we invest $10,000 USD into Japanese equities at the beginning of 1990 and $10,000 every year thereafter, by the end of 1996 that would be worth $49,448.41, that’s $20,551.59 less than our total $70,000 in contributions.
In the year 2022, our portfolio finishes off at $581,691 after $320,000 of contributions. Not great returns, but at least they’re positive. When we account for the DCAing our MWRR (money-weighted rate of return) comes out to be 2.94% a year.
It Still Looks Pretty Bleak Though…
We may have gotten away with a positive return, but that doesn’t necessarily mean that our investment grows to something we can retire comfortably on.
I don’t usually like to hate on index fund investing too much, but this data right here shows one of the flaws of the approach. Our fundamental assumption is that the market will always go up, which for all we know, it should. But in the case of Japan, it didn’t, and dollar-cost averaging simply shifts your returns from negative to positive, but not by enough of a margin to have a good amount of money for retirement.
So what to do…
Well, the first most obvious answer and one advocated by indexers, is to invest in a globally diversified equities ETF to get exposure all around the globe. This avoids something like what happened to Japan, from happening to us.
Again, a small caveat here, eventually most markets will mature as they move further into first-world territory where we have a higher risk of flat markets. If a lot of these markets around the globe begin to stagnate, then our growth will be significantly slowed.
You might be thinking “this is a stupid thing to worry about.” And maybe it is, but it’s also possible, so let’s not dismiss it entirely.
The second idea to mitigate this, and something I really don’t hear being advocated anywhere is a buy-write strategy. A buy-write strategy essentially boils down to buying securities and then selling call options on them to generate premiums. During bull markets, this usually underperforms since stock appreciation is at such high levels. However, when markets are flat we can still sell options that then expire worthless thus generating a sort of “dividend.” Historically this has outperformed flat markets in the US by a significant margin.
You can do this by yourself by simply selling options directly on the indexes that you own through your brokerage, or you can invest in a fund that will do it for you (for a fee) like QYLD or XYLD. Both of these funds either invest in QQQ or SPY and then sell call options on the stock that they own.
As of now, I don’t have any other ideas to mitigate the pitfalls of a flat or stagnant market. However, if you have any ideas, leave them in the comments below! I would love to hear them. Hopefully, this article has jogged your brain on the topic and we can continue to explore it. And by the way, if you liked this article, be sure to forward it to a friend, it only takes a couple of clicks of your mouse and helps me out a lot!
About our guest author
Hey! My name is Tyler and I’m the author of Premium Income Investments. My goal is to write informative, data-driven articles that show opportunities for us to outperform the stock market averages.
Hopefully along the way you and I can learn new things about the financial markets together. If you have a thought-provoking investing idea I would love to hear it! You can reach out to me in the comments of any of my articles or email me directly on my Substack. My newsletter is completely free to subscribe to, (in fact you don’t even need to subscribe to read it, but I would appreciate it if you do) and I send out one a week, so you don’t need to worry about spam. Here’s to finding new investment opportunities.
Follow me on Instagram @premium.income.investments or on Twitter @premiumincomes